Round 2: The Eccentric Family vs. Rozen Maiden, Parasyte vs. Psycho Pass 2

eccentric family 3

The Eccentric Family – Episode 3

“It’s so dense, every single image has so many things going on.” This quote from Rick McCallum, infamous producer of the Star Wars prequels, popped into my head more than once while watching this episode. Just look at the screenshot above – that level of background detail easily matches that of Mushishi, which is no mean feat. Unlike the newer Star Wars films, however, Uchouten Kazoku has a story worth following, even if that can be a difficult task at times. This week especially I felt as though the unfamiliar names of tengu clans, past conflicts, and unseen characters were whizzing by all too quickly. That conversational style was no detriment to my enjoyment of the episode, however, as I followed the overarching plot of the episode from start to finish, and greatly enjoyed the art and atmosphere as usual.

The Gozan Fire Festival is quickly approaching for our eccentric family, and before that day comes they’ll need to borrow Professor Akadama’s “flying inner parlor” to participate in the aerial celebration. Yasaburo asks his former teacher to borrow it, but the old codger has given it to Benten, a revelation which prompts a fit of jealousy from Yasaburo. Even though there are plenty of romantic feelings between the three of them, it’s interesting to note that Yasaburo and Benten share a type of sibling relationship as well, with Akadama functioning as the father. This is a series that laces each piece of dialogue with as much meaning as it can muster, and that holds true for the ending scene between Yasaburo and Benten at the sunken clock tower. 99% of romance in anime is dull and formulaic, resulting in audience arguments about “best girls” and which cast member will “win” by hooking up with the main character. These are stupid, superficial lines of conversation, but what else is there to talk about when your characters are so paper-thin? Not so with The Eccentric Family, which nails the complicated, true-to-life feeling of crushing on someone who you know could really hurt you. Benten’s association with the Friday Fellows, who treat tanuki as a delicacy, makes her a dangerous acquaintance, and her abilities to fly and control the weather make her powerful and potentially threatening, but she’s also attractive, fun-loving and agreeable, and in the end she does lend the inner parlor to her friend.

There’s a lot more I want to write about that clock tower scene, but I really do need to start limiting these recaps to just a paragraph each, at least until the field is narrowed down to just 16 shows or so. This is a great series that I expect will make Top 8 at the very least, so hopefully I can do some more thorough analysis of its characters and themes in a couple weeks.

rozen maiden 3-3

Rozen Maiden (2013) – Episode 3

Even though Sabagebu! and Hoozuki no Reitetsu were seeded lower, this incarnation of Rozen Maiden is probably the most surprising success of the tournament. This is a sequel to a 2004 TV series I’ve never watched, which is based on a manga about dolls fighting that I’ve never read. All I knew going is was that time travel and/or alternate universes were involved somehow, but there’s no way I could have expected the series to be both this engaging and this low-key. Of all the introverted slacker protagonists I’ve seen in anime (and if you’ve seen my MAL you know that’s not many, so take this with a grain of salt), Jun is among the most relatable. His hatred of his job doesn’t lead him on winding internal monologues about how the whole world is rotten to the core. He doesn’t obsess over his female co-worker, nor does he ice her out. He has a hobby that he’s passionate about, which feels normal thanks to an unobtrusive series of flashbacks around the episode’s middle. From what I understand, the dolls were the main characters of the original series, but this time Jun is carrying most of the narrative weight, and doing a great job of it.

The Verdict: Rozen Maiden has been surprisingly good, but The Eccentric Family has been consistently great. I’m still very excited to see both series to completion, though.


parasyte 3

Parayste – Episode 3

This was easily the best cliffhanger of the tournament so far. Every scene in this show carries some ideological weight behind it, and the confrontation between “A” and the duo of Shinichi and Migi is no different. “A” claims that he “will eat when he is hungry, and eliminate any who stand in his way.” Shinichi, on the other hand, is capable of empathy and selflessness, which we see in his horrified reaction to Migi’s plan to use his classmates as a wall of meat. The thing that makes this show stand out, though, is that the characters aren’t just walking mouthpieces for their respective philosophies. If A’s sole concern were subsistence, he wouldn’t target Shinichi, whose parasitic right hand makes him much more difficult prey than the average human. Instead, he may be targeting him due to anger at their conflicting world views, or to assert dominance, or even because he views Shinichi as a threat to his sexual relationship with Tamura. Whatever the case may be, he has some motivation for his actions, which gives meaning to the upcoming battle and increases our anticipation for the event.

Just as interesting, though, were the revelations that there are other parasites who have managed to retain some element of their host’s humanity, or at least disguise themselves as humans quite effectively. One of these is Shinichi’s math teacher, who reveals over lunch that after having sex with A, she became pregnant with a perfectly ordinary baby. Her desire to fit into human society makes sense, then, although with Tamura it’s a little harder to tell whether she’s only interested in self-preservation, or if she has any maternal instinct towards her unborn human child. Judging by her neutral, almost bored expression as she delivered the news of her pregnancy, I’d lean towards the former, but as Parasyte goes on I have a feeling that the line between humans and parasites will become blurred to some extent. Very keen to see more of this show.

psycho pass 3-2

Psycho Pass 2 – Episode 3

This was a step up from the last episode for sure, although a large part of this episode’s success must be attributed to its opening scene. Finally we got a lengthy look at Kamui, our villain, who has captured an Inspector, ripped out her right eye, and suspended it in some magical liquid so she can monitor her own crime coefficient. It’s a fascinating setup, and his goal – to make everyone’s hue clear and break Sibyl’s hold on society – is just as interesting, although Stockholm Syndrome has set in for his prisoner a little too quickly to be believed. All he did was speak in a soothing tone of voice and let her chew on his thumb for a bit. I’m guessing that whatever drug was in that IV drip is what’s actually responsible for lowering her crime coefficient, as well as calming her down despite her foreign surroundings. All in all, this was one of the better cold opens I’ve seen so far, but how did the rest of the episode fare?

Not as well, I’m afraid. Lots of conversations and no action were the orders of the day here, and I’m not necessarily against that (I liked the first Psycho Pass, after all), but like I said last time, this show is going to live or die as a thriller. I just wrote about characters serving as mouthpieces under the Parayste recap above, and that’s exactly the problem with this sequel: some of these characters are just names and colons on a script. Musings on identity and technology are always welcome, but when they dominate the proceedings to this degree, they need to be brilliant rather than just serviceable. And when you remove my investment in returning characters like Akane and Ginoza from the equation as well, it becomes a bit clearer that Psycho Pass 2 is merely getting by. The revelation that Togane’s crime coefficient was at one point the highest in recorded history was intriguing, though, so I’ll be watching to see how the writers handle that plot thread.

Disclaimer: Because the show has finished airing, I’ve had the chance to read a lot of criticism of Psycho Pass 2’s subpar plotting and resolution, which may have colored my views on this episode.

The Verdict: A great cliffhanger from Parasyte beats out a great cold open from its opponent. Plus, you know, better story and characters.


NEXT UP: Gundam vs. Tokyo Ghoul, Stardust Crusaders vs. Ace of Diamond

For the first time so far this tournament, the losing series in these matchups will be dropped from the bracket. I’m predicting victories for Tokyo Ghoul and Stardust Crusaders, but both of those series were upset by lower seeds in the first round, so it could happen again here!

Advertisements

Round 1: Parasyte vs. Hitsugi no Chaika, Psycho-Pass 2 vs. Ao Haru Ride

Finally we’ve reached the end of the first round. A few weeks ago I said I wanted to accelerate this tournament so I’d be ready to start a new one in time for the winter 2015 season, but obviously that didn’t happen. I’m not too bummed about it, though, since there are only five shows I’m interested in watching this winter (here they are for reference). For now I’ll just be focusing on finishing this tournament, sharpening my writing skills, fiddling with the blog layout, etc. Let’s get to the matches!

parasyte 2-3

Parasyte – Episode 2

There was some legitimately terrible animation during the first half of this episode, during the basketball scene and the fight directly afterwards. All the transformations and twisting body parts probably suck Parasyte’s budget totally dry each week, but damn, the lack of fluidity during sports and combat scenes stuck out like a sore thumb. And this a Madhouse series, too! Thankfully, the rest of the episode looked much better, or else the story was more engaging and I didn’t have the time to think what a drastic step down the visuals took from last week.

Whenever you’re dealing with a series where humans aren’t at the top of the food chain, you can expect some dialogue about the value of human life to crop up. Parasyte went that route this week, and acquitted itself well. Shinichi’s alien-infested right hand (now named “Migi”) is a curious, rational creature, and thankfully doesn’t get into some philosophical argument when its host insists that the killing of humans for sustenance is wrong, instead repeating several times that it can’t understand. But its “does not compute” attitude is tempered by its human personality, so it doesn’t lean too far in either direction. The Shinichi/Migi relationship is an interesting one, but there’s a lot of foreshadowing here that an actual relationship may develop between Shinichi and Satomi. Migi’s sexual curiosity is just as strong as a teenage boy’s, so this may become one of the most awkward romances in fictional history. What happens when a host mates with a plain old human? If the last scene of this episode is any indication, we’ll find out soon enough.

chaika 2

Hitsugi no Chaika – Episode 2

What does it say about Chaika’s direction that the image above was the most striking one I could find this week? There was a failure to entertain on all fronts here. Even Chaika, the series’ standout character, just blended into the background. That doesn’t mean the story at the heart of this episode was incompetently told – we haven’t reached Gundam or Sekai Seifuku levels of terribleness here – only that it didn’t inspire me to watch the next one. And when your story revolves around the daughter of a magical emperor traveling the world to reclaim his scattered limbs and give him a proper burial, that isn’t a good sign.

Maybe my lack of excitement has something to do with the calm, almost disinterested way that Toru absorbs all the crazy information being thrown at him. The girl he’s working for should be dead? Doesn’t matter, keep moving. The item they were trying to retrieve was a glowing magical hand? Briefly ask about its significance, then drop it. Letting Chaika roam free might throw the world back into war? Sounds good, bring it on. Toru is a saboteur, so he’s used to taking orders and not asking too many questions, but he and his sister only seem to be along for the ride in this potentially universe-altering conflict, which makes them a little boring. We’ll see whether this show can last a couple more episodes and give its antagonists some personality to compensate.

The Verdict: In a battle between two poorly-animated series from two titanic animation houses, Parasyte wins on the strength of its characters and story alone.


psycho pass 2

Psycho Pass 2 – Episode 2

My recollection of Psycho Pass’s first season is that the first half focused on a handful of individual cases, while the second was dedicated entirely to the MWPSB’s pursuit of Makishima. It looks like this season may cut out the episodic stuff and jump straight to the hunt for our shadowy big bad, whose existence has already been theorized by Akane. Working with only 11 episodes compared to 22 definitely forces the writers’ collective hand in that regard. I definitely enjoy this series more as a thriller than as a procedural, so this could be a good thing, but on the other hand I feel as though the new characters are being glossed over. Akane’s female partner has only one personality trait so far, and that’s “nag.” The redhead is just another tech head at this point, and Togane’s brief time in the limelight didn’t do much for me, which was a shame since he’s clearly supposed to be the new Kogami. It looks like this show’s survivability will be based on plot alone.

shot0009

Ao Haru Ride – Episode 2

This week’s Ao Haru Ride opens with another watercolor flashback, this time for a game of cops and robbers. Destined lovers Futaba and Tanaka end up hiding together, and she uses the opportunity to smell his shampoo. Tanaka catches her in the act, but recovers quite nicely, excusing himself to make a break for the safe zone. When he’s caught moments later, Futaba jumps to the conclusion that his capture was her fault, which means she has to save him. PAUSE. What part of your future baby daddy’s failure to win a glorified game of tag are you responsible for, exactly? You didn’t give away his position. You didn’t tie his shoelaces together. What you did was invade his personal space, which made things a little awkward and caused him to abandon his hiding spot, but he would have had to do that eventually to win the game. The stupefying trend of shoujo protagonists berating themselves over the smallest things (especially things over which they have no control) needs to stop.

And that’s just the first two or three minutes. This show’s grasp of high school politics is about as good as Gingitsune’s, which is to say it’s terrible. These girls are dialogue-generating robots who argue over popularity and proper flirting technique by tossing out lines such as (and I’m paraphrasing here), “If you think that acting cute to get boys’ attention is cheating, then you must care whether boys pay attention to you, too!” Thus it is proven, I guess? After Futaba’s big fight with her friends, she runs into Tanaka, who offers her the most non-commital hug of all time: not only does Futaba assume he did it just to hide her tears from approaching students, but he walks away immediately afterwards while brushing off her questions. That’s what girls like, right? Ugh. This show is dumb beyond belief. I really hope Chaika steps up its game in the next round so I don’t have to watch past episode 3 of this series.

The Verdict: Both shows produced major duds this week, but Psycho Pass 2’s dialogue was less cringe-worthy. (Did I really just type that sentence?)


Updated bracket coming soon!

First Impressions: Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure: Stardust Crusaders, Ao Haru Ride, Parasyte, Tokyo Ghoul

We did it folks. It took a lot longer than the one week I was anticipating, but the seeding process is finally complete. Just these four previews to go, and then I’ll create a separate post for the bracket so we can get this tournament underway!

jojo 1-2

Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure: Stardust Crusaders

The third and final sequel entered in this tournament, Stardust Crusaders has a lot to live up to in the original Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure, a shounen fighting series so old that it’s managed to both establish and subvert every trope in the book. Thankfully, based on this premiere, I’d say it’s on the right track. David Production clearly has a bigger budget this time around, as the animation is much flashier than it was last season. It’s not so smooth that it loses the charm of Hirohiko Araki’s 80s character designs, though. Speaking of which, I love Joseph Joestar’s character design (pictured above) as a grandfather who’s dragged back into the fight against evil after his father’s murderer returns to life using Jonathan’s body. And now that he’s working alongside his grandson, Jotaro, there’s all sorts of potential for family drama. Jotaro’s attitude towards his mother was a problem for me, but it’s consistent with JJBA’s relegation of women to passive roles. The 1980s were a different time, I guess. That’s just a small blemish on an episode that set up a lot of promising dominos, however, so I have high hopes for this sequel to deliver the same adrenaline-pumping action and campy style as its predecessor.

ao haru ride 1

Ao Haru Ride

Ao Haru Ride’s first episode starts off rather well, with a pretty watercolor visual style and a convincing depiction of an awkward fateful encounter in the rain. The idealism in the art and the realism of the dialogue formed a perfect contrast, so for one brief and shining moment I thought this would be something more than the standard shoujo romance I had figured it would be when I selected it for the tournament. Unfortunately, as soon as the series flashed forward to the present, the watercolor style disappeared and the characters flatlined. Female lead is late for school? Check. Her friends make fun of the weird girl in class? Check. Girl explains the measures she took to achieve some measure of popularity? Check. Girl doesn’t understand why guy she likes is nice to her one minute and aloof the next? Check.

The hook here is that the boy in the watercolor flashback moved away, ruining any shot that he and Futaba had at romance. Several years later, though, he returns to town as a teacher, having changed his name and personality. I guess he skipped several grades during his absence, or else I just misunderstood his request that his former classmates call him “sensei.” This might have grabbed my interest if the conversation between the two leads hadn’t been so stereotypically hot and cold, and Futaba’s reaction hadn’t been so predictably confused. This show gets some points for featuring a high school cast rather than Shigatsu’s middle school students, but I’d say the latter had a better first episode.

parasyte 1-6

Parasyte -the maxim-

This was one of the best first episodes of the tournament, and probably the best anime episode I’ve ever watched that featured a boob grab. Apparently that scene wasn’t in the manga, but since Shinichi’s right hand quite literally has a mind of its own, it gets a pass. Everything else was phenomenal. Using the alien burrowing scene as a flashback (rather than opening with it) was smart, because it allowed the director to cultivate a curiosity about who was talking to Shinichi that morning, and what his dad meant by, “Did you find the snake?” There’s an ah-hah! moment when the flashback finally comes, because we already know how he stops the alien’s progress through his arm, but the scene retains a sense of urgency because of some killer direction.

The evolution of both main characters is paced very nicely: the alien uses Google and reads biology textbooks to gain a massive amount of knowledge in a short period of time, while Shinichi takes baby steps by increasing his appetite (what a courteous host) and relinquishing his fear of bugs. Despite Shinichi’s fear and confusion at what’s happening to him, he and his new parasite appear destined for a symbiotic relationship. The alien’s cute voice and visible disappointment at having failed to reach his host’s brain are important tools in making it a sympathetic character, and Shinichi’s horrified reactions to his affliction lend a tense, realistic atmosphere to an unrealistic premise. I even find that the heavy use of dubstep, which a lot of bloggers are taking issue with, helps evoke an unsettling mood that goes nicely with the series’ subject matter.

I don’t want to write as much about this show as I did about Mushishi, but I could. It’s that good. They’re on opposite sides of the bracket, so if they both keep winning, they won’t play until Round 5. What a match that would be.

shot0054

Tokyo Ghoul

The two horror series in the tournament ended up being the last two shows I watched. Aside from the fact that both main characters are part human and part something else, however, Tokyo Ghoul is very different from Parasyte. The scope of the story is much larger right off the bat: the cold open here features a masked ghoul hunter, very likely some kind of supernatural creature himself, with “orders from above” to capture another ghoul alive. Elsewhere there’s talk of distributing feeding grounds, managing wards of Ghouls, and an organization called Anteiku, regarded by opponents as fence-sitters but who wield a lot of influence nonetheless. All of these potential plot points are only briefly alluded to, which creates a lot of questions for the next episode to answer.

Protagonist Kaneki becomes half ghoul when the organs of another ghoul who nearly killed him are transplanted into his body. His sense of taste deteriorates, he tries and fails to injure himself, and eventually he’s driven by hunger to seek human flesh for himself. All of this is stylishly animated by Studio Pierrot, but I wasn’t fully engaged during this episode, well-produced as it was. The periodic censorship of gorier images may have contributed to that feeling, but beyond that I’m not connecting with Kaneki very well. To throw all delicacy out the window, the guy is a wimp. Obviously this first episode put him through hell, but so far he’s not the kind of main character I can really root for. Still, this was a solid premiere, so I’ll gladly watch another couple episodes at least.


And so, First Impressions week comes to a close. I’ll be posting the bracket shortly, along with some thoughts on the current crop of shows and which matchups to keep an eye on going into Round 1.